David, Peter
AVERAGE REVIEW SCORE:
2.8 out of 5
(4 books)
TOP PICK:
Fallen Angel
Fallen Angel
(Art by David Lopez and Fernando Blanco)
In the corrupt city of Bete Noire those in need seek out Lee, a woman also known as the Fallen Angel. Lee walks the shadowy line between justice and Bete Noire's criminal underworld, her origins mysterious, but her superhuman power clear to anyone who gets in her way.
Although published by DC Comics, this book feels more of a Vertigo imprint style of story (and certainly doesn't appear to be part of the same universe as Batman or Superman). It's a far more adult book than standard DC fare, with sex and violence threaded throughout. However, it still feels like a superhero story. Sure, Lee is probably more of an anti-hero than outright hero, but her late night meetings with informants on rooftops was very reminiscent of the like of Batman. At times it goes as far as to feel almost a pastiche or parody of gothic superheroes, although the book never comes close to being considered comedic.
Despite the slightly derivative tone of the book, I nevertheless found it an enjoyable read. Lee is a compellingly direct protagonist, who refuses to be intimidated by the criminal men who view her as little more than a pretty face. There are also hints of a tragic and mysterious backstory to her which suggest she may actually be a literal fallen angel. Unfortunately we get nothing more than hints, but it still makes Lee feel like a character with depth.
4 out of 5
Halo: Helljumper
(Art by Eric Nguyen)
When the Covenant invade an otherwise unimportant archaeological site a squad of ODST Helljumpers is sent in to ruin their day and find out what it is the aliens are digging for.
This is a pretty bare-bones story, with the 'Covenant hunting for Forerunner artifact with humans in the way' plot feeling pretty derivative and unremarkable. However, I did like that this story doesn't feature the superhuman Spartans at all for a change and instead we get to see how elite (pardon the pun) but ordinary soldiers fare against the Covenant. Even the Grunts manage to seem more threatening here and it adds an air of danger that probably wouldn't be present if the Master Chief was there, guns blazing.
Honestly, my biggest problem with this book, and what tempted me to rate it lower, is Eric Nguyen's artwork. It's mostly pretty solid, but every two to three pages there's a big splash panel that's such a jumbled mess that I had to stop every time and try to puzzle out what was supposed to be happening. This seems to be a case of the artist forgetting that they're not just there to create images but it's also their job to help tell the story.
3 out of 5
House Of M: The Incredible Hulk
(Art by Jorge Lucas, Adam Kubert, John Dell and Scott Hanna)
This is a tie-in to Brian Michael Bendis' 'House Of M', in which the Scarlet Witch uses her power to create an alternate reality. In this reality the world is ruled by mutants (led by Magneto's House of M) and the world's superheroes have been granted idyllic lifestyles.
This book begins with Bruce Banner finally having found peace among an aboriginal tribe in Australia. However, that peace is interrupted by A.I.M, who recruit the Hulk for their war against the mutants. When A.I.M proves untrustworthy, Banner decides to rule the human-haven of Australia on his own.
Unlike the Spider-Man and Wolverine equivalent tie-ins, this book also shows us the immediate aftermath of when the Scarlet Witch returns the world to normal (albeit minus 99% of the world's mutants). Once more the Hulk has the chance of peace with the aboriginies, but it is disturbed by conflict between A.I.M and S.H.I.E.L.D, represented by mother and daughter Dr Rappaccini and Scorpion respectively.
I felt that the 'what if?' scenario presented here just wasn't strong enough to make the most of its potential. So, I found that much like the first Hulk movie, it's fine when the large green fella is smashing stuff, but it becomes ponderous when he's not. That said, it's worth reading for the scene in which Hulk throws chunks of the Sydney Opera House at an enemy and then proceeds to flatten the rest of the building. When asked why he did that for no reason, he amusingly responds "Had a reason. Can't stand opera."
3 out of 5
Wolverine: Blood Hungry
(Art by Sam Keith)
Living as part of the criminal underworld in Madripoor, Logan discovers that a feared enemy has arrived in the city looking to seize control of that underworld. He is then forced to confront his own fear and half-remembered past as he tackles Cyber, the man with the adamantium skin.
Here's the short version; I don't like Madripoor as a setting, I didn't like Cyber as the antagonist, I hated the misguided attempts at humour between Tyger Tiger and General Coy, and I really didn't like Sam Keith's artwork. So, here's the even shorter version; I didn't like this book.
This already short story is made up of fragments from eight separate issues of 'Marvel Comics Presents' and therefore really struggles to hold together a cohesive narrative, as well as it being painfully obvious that this was B- or C-story in an anthology comic.
Honestly, I can't think of a single thing I liked about this book (except, perhaps, that is was short).
1 out of 5
Collaborations & Anthologies:
Batman: Knightquest - The Crusade: Volume 2 (here)
Civil War: X-Men Universe (here)
Madrox The Multiple Man: Multiple Choice/Madrox The Multiple Man! (here)
Marvel Versus DC/DC Versus Marvel (here)
Onslaught 4: Eye Of The Storm (here)
Polaris: Who Dares Defy... The Demi-Men?/Not Brand X (here)
Professor X: Psi-War/The Muir Island Saga (here)
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine - Wrath Of The Prophets (here)
Star Wars: Tales - Volume 1 (here)
The Avengers: Road To Marvel's The Avengers (here)
Thunderbolts: Justice, Like Lightning... (here)
Young Justice: A League Of Their Own (here)